Susie's Pizza

Discover Susie's Pizza in Upper Sandusky, OH – renowned for delicious subs, flavorful sauces, friendly staff, and a cash-only experience. Enjoy quick drive-up service at 203 S Sandusky Ave. Call +1 419-294-3555 today!

Welcome to Susie's Pizza

Taste the Difference.

Susie's Pizza
Susie's Pizza
Susie's Pizza
Susie's Pizza

Discover Susie's Pizza, a hidden gem nestled at 203 S Sandusky Ave in Upper Sandusky, Ohio. This welcoming pizza restaurant creates a culinary experience that keeps locals coming back. Known for its cash-only policy, Susie's serves delicious specialty pizzas that elevate traditional flavors. From BBQ Chicken to Buffalo Chicken, each pie features the finest ingredients prepared with care. Friendly staff members add warmth to the atmosphere, making it a perfect spot to enjoy a meal with friends or family. Whether dining in or grabbing a quick bite to go, Susie’s offers a casual vibe that’s perfect for everyone. Ask the locals; they all have a favorite dish here.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

203 S Sandusky Ave, Upper Sandusky, OH 43351, United States

Phone

+1 419-294-3555

About

The Culinary Story

Susie's Pizza
Susie's Pizza
Susie's Pizza
Susie's Pizza

For years, Susie's Pizza has been a cornerstone of the Upper Sandusky community, offering not just food but a friendly gathering place. Established to bring unique flavors to traditional pizza, the restaurant has earned a dedicated following. The secret? Fresh ingredients and a focus on flavor. Each specialty pizza is a testament to the staff's commitment to quality, ensuring every bite delivers satisfaction.

The menu features four signature pizzas that approach perfection: BBQ Chicken, Ranch Chicken, Buffalo Chicken, and Chick. Bacon Ranch. Each recipe boasts a balance of bold flavors, crispy crusts, and savory toppings.

It's not just about the pizza; the range of subs—like Ham & Cheese and the Bacon Chicken Ranch—offers something for everyone. Patrons can savor different options, and their salty cravings are met with a touch of homemade sauce that becomes their signature touch.

In addition to the menu, the restaurant’s community engagement shines. Hosting local events and supporting local farmers adds to its charm. Various promotions, like family night specials, encourage friends and family to come together over a delicious meal. This commitment to community makes Susie's Pizza more than just a dining stop; it’s a place where memories are made.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday4-9:30 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday4-8:30 PM
  • Wednesday4-9:30 PM
  • Thursday4-9:30 PM
  • Friday4-9:30 PM
  • Saturday4-9:30 PM

Susie's Pizza stands out with a diverse menu that includes 17 mouthwatering options. Specialty pizzas take center stage, featuring unique combinations like Chick. Bacon Ranch and Ranch Chicken, ensuring every visit offers something new to explore. The menu doesn’t stop here; it also includes satisfying sub sandwiches and fresh salads. Try the Italian Sub for a hearty option or the Chef Salad, which makes for a great lighter choice.

The atmosphere is laid-back, perfect for quick lunches or relaxed dinners, and outdoor seating offers a charming view of the bustling street.

Plus, parking is convenient for those picking up delicious pizza on the go. Cash-only transactions add a touch of old-school charm, reinforcing a focus on quality food without the fuss.

Susie's Pizza

The exterior of Susie's Pizza captures a quaint, welcoming atmosphere that feels like home to many Upper Sandusky residents. With cheerful signage and bright red accents, it stands out against the backdrop of charming storefronts. Once inside, the casual decor invites comfort, reinforced by community photographs celebrating its history. Outdoor seating creates the ideal setting for enjoying a pizza in the fresh air, especially during the lively summer months.

The vibe here is distinctly friendly, where customers feel appreciated and often greet familiar faces, creating a robust community feel. This restaurant isn’t just about pizza; it’s about shared experiences and friendly exchanges, which makes each visit special.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Susie's has always been my favorite pizza place. The staff is so friendly, the pizza is always so good. The personal touch is always when they know you by name!

B
Brittany A.

Best pizza in upper Sandusky!! You get what you pay for here, they don't skimp on your toppings!! There subs are delicious!! Everything is cooked to perfection!! I only wish they would deliver to kirby because then they would be the only pizza I would ever order!!

J
Jaclyn M.

Their Sandwiches were Fantastic!!! Very accommodating and personable. CASH ONLY!

R
Robert M.

Best pizza in the state Drive from north east Ohio a few times a year and always order from here And the delivery driver is polite and friendly All around a great place

J
J. M.

I ordered two days in a row from Susie's. I'm an over-the-road truck driver stayed at the pilot and I had pizza last night was the best pizza I could have ever eaten. It was a turning. Sorry. I couldn't finish it. The delivery person has been very nice. And the first night. I had boneless chicken wings, which were excellent had a little bit too much barbecue sauce, but they're still good and I had garlic sticks or something, whatever great. Wish I had a place like that around me in, Florida.

R
Ronald L.

This is definitely one of the top pizza places in town. Love the history and how long it's been in town.

E
Elijah M.